News

Wheatland Schoolhouse: A Historic Converted Rental in Churchville, NY

A historic one-room schoolhouse restored by Nicholas & James · Churchville, New York

Some buildings wait patiently for the right people.

In a quiet stretch of Churchville, New York—where farmland opens wide and the pace never quite rushes—the Wheatland Schoolhouse has stood since 1867. Once a one-room school serving six or seven farming families, it later became an economy apartment, then a long-neglected rental, slowly slipping into disrepair. Lowered ceilings hid its volume. Vinyl windows dulled its presence. Squirrels made themselves at home. Time, mostly, took over.

When James found it, the schoolhouse was less a dream than a commitment. He was thirty, looking for a project, and willing to take on something that most people would walk away from. It would become his biggest undertaking—one that eventually pulled Nicholas into its orbit, both personally and creatively.

__wf_reserved_inherit
Kindergarten days: Children and their teachers in the original one-room schoolhouse, long before it was restored.

A Long Way Back

The Wheatland Schoolhouse was the third building to stand on that township site, and it carried the weight of its years. Decades of neglect had left their mark—damaged floors, poor insulation, invasive wildlife, and rot hidden behind the walls. What remained wasn’t precious so much as vulnerable, requiring careful attention rather than cosmetic fixes.

James led the demolition and general contracting himself. As the interior was taken back to its bones, it became clear that nothing original could be saved. Floors were resupported, insulation replaced entirely, and a large tree removed. Even the structure itself needed reinforcement, with metal cables threaded through the loft floor to help keep the building intact.

Nicholas joined the project as they were dating, stepping into the work as the rebuild took shape. What followed was less a renovation than a thoughtful reconstruction—one shaped by patience, problem-solving, and a deep respect for the building’s history and role in the community. Neighbors who remembered the schoolhouse in its most neglected years watched it slowly return, transformed from something overlooked into something cared for again.

The cost of the work ultimately rivaled the purchase price itself. But this was never about shortcuts or surface-level solutions. Every decision responded directly to the condition of the building, prioritizing longevity, soundness, and integrity over speed.
‍

__wf_reserved_inherit
Before the rebuild: Decades of wear and neglect, hinting at the care the space would soon require.

Holding the Line on History

From the road, the Wheatland Schoolhouse still reads clearly as what it has always been.

Nicholas and James were intentional about preserving that recognition. They removed years of added “cottage” elements—plastic shutters, decorative distractions—and allowed the original brickwork to come forward again. The historic marble plaque was protected and left unobscured. Landscaping was used to quietly screen modern life, keeping the focus on the structure itself.

That clean slate became an opportunity rather than a loss.

__wf_reserved_inherit
Post-demo shell: The building’s historic bones exposed, ready for a thoughtful reinvention.

Inside, a New Chapter

With no original interior elements to preserve, the design shifted inward with clarity and restraint. The interior is modern, calm, and grounded—meant to function as a real home rather than a temporary stay.

Italian mid-century dining chairs sourced from Brimfield sit alongside an Indian wedding table, reimagined as a banquette. Pieces feel chosen, not styled. Practical, but full of character. The layout prioritizes light, proportion, and quiet moments—spaces designed to be lived in, not passed through.

Despite its rural setting, the house feels gently insulated from the outside world. Light moves through the space in a way that still reflects its original purpose, giving mornings a particular softness that feels unforced.

__wf_reserved_inherit
New furnishings: Thoughtfully selected pieces that bring contemporary comfort and clean lines to the space.
__wf_reserved_inherit
Modern Kitchen – A light-filled, functional space that balances simplicity with timelessness. An antique copper pot—once belonging to a friend’s grandparents—rests on the stove, while historic photographs quietly reference the building’s past.
__wf_reserved_inherit
Bird’s-eye view: Dining and living areas seen from above, highlighting openness and flow. Throughout the home, thoughtfully chosen antique pieces add depth and story.
__wf_reserved_inherit
Brimfield find — Arrben-made Italian leather dining chairs, discovered at Brimfield and selected for their quiet mid-century character and worn-in texture.
__wf_reserved_inherit
Primary Bedroom – Set in the loft, this airy retreat features a king bed, a relaxed sitting area, and a private bath—designed for slow mornings and quiet evenings.
__wf_reserved_inherit
Secondary bedroom: A light-filled retreat that quietly nods to the home’s history. Located on the main floor, it features a queen bed and easy bathroom access via a pocket door.
__wf_reserved_inherit
Original beams: James preserved the schoolhouse’s wood beams, giving the interior the warmth and vertical drama of an A-frame.
__wf_reserved_inherit
James arranging hydrangeas for a guest, tending to the home with quiet, thoughtful care.

Honoring History

‍The Wheatland Schoolhouse No. 7 is recognized by the Landmark Acknowledgment Society, a testament to its importance in Monroe County’s architectural and community heritage. When James Arlington purchased the building in 2021, it required extensive restoration, and he approached the project with patience and commitment. Nicholas Roes joined the effort, bringing a creative eye and a deep respect for the schoolhouse’s story. Together, they carefully reinforced the structure, removed decades of unsympathetic alterations, and reimagined the interior for modern living—returning the schoolhouse to use while honoring its original character. Their work ensures the building remains a functional, cherished part of the community, bridging past and present with care and intention.

__wf_reserved_inherit
Wheatland Schoolhouse No. 7: A Historic Win for the Community
__wf_reserved_inherit
Nic and James, the owners behind the church—thoughtful stewards of its history and next chapter.


A Building, Returned

What defines the Wheatland Schoolhouse today isn’t just its design—it’s the care behind it. The work was slow, hands-on, and deeply considered. Neighbors watched a familiar building come back to life, transformed from something overlooked into something quietly admired again.

“It is very peaceful and quiet… you can tell it was a school because of the way it’s oriented to the light… You’re just kind of stuck in time out there.”
— Nicholas Roes

Where there was once neglect, there is now intention. Where ceilings once pressed down, there is space—and light. The schoolhouse hasn’t been reinvented; it has been returned, thoughtfully and with respect. And sometimes, that’s where the real beauty lives.

With two bedrooms, two full baths, and space to sleep four comfortably, the Wheatland Schoolhouse is available to book directly. No platforms, no layers—just a thoughtful stay, shared as it was meant to be experienced.

Interview & editing
Justin Henry
|
Photography
Nicholas Roes
Owners
Nicholas Roes
|
Remodel: James Arlington and Nicholas Roes
Justin Henry
About the editor

Justin Henry is the founder and editor of Locèlle, telling the stories of design-led homes and the people who build them.

Read the letter from the founders

Own a home with a story of its own? Submit your home to Locèlle

For owners

Own a home like this? See what you could keep.

Airbnb and Vrbo take about 15% of every booking. Answer four quick questions and see what booking direct could be worth to you.

Try the calculator
Why Book This House

Step into history, stay in comfort

Wheatland Schoolhouse No.07
Wheatland Schoolhouse No.07
300
View home