Unique Stays

Unique Vacation Rentals on Fire Island

Design-led summer houses in Fire Island Pines, reached by ferry and boardwalk. Book directly with the owners.

Unique Vacation Rentals on Fire Island

Homes featured in

Architectural Digest
The New York Times
Dwell
Magnolia Network
Condé Nast Traveler
ArchDaily
Country Living
Sunset

Get the Drops

Be first to new stays in

Fire Island, NY

Owners share new homes with us before they're listed anywhere else. Get them first in a weekly email, and book direct with the owner.

About the area

Fire Island is a long, narrow barrier island off the South Shore of Long Island, with the Atlantic on one side and the Great South Bay on the other. Most of its communities have no cars at all. You arrive by ferry, pull your bags along wooden boardwalks, and spend the days between the ocean beach, the pool and the harbor.

Fire Island Pines and its neighbor Cherry Grove are two of the country's best-known LGBTQ+ summer communities, and the Pines is also home to a remarkable collection of modern beach houses. The homes on this page come from that tradition. 625 Shore Walk is a cedar-clad modern house set behind a boardwalk in the pines, with skylights, a double-height entry, a heated pool on a wide deck and bold printed wallpaper in every room.

Every home on Locèlle is listed by its owner. You see the house, you meet the host, and you book with them directly, without added platform fees.

Why stay here

  • No cars. Boardwalks, ferries and bare feet. The pace changes the moment you step off the boat.
  • Ocean and bay. A wide Atlantic beach on one side, calm bay water and sunsets over the harbor on the other.
  • Modern beach houses. The Pines has some of the most interesting modern summer houses on the East Coast.
  • A summer with traditions. Tea dances at the harbor, the Invasion of the Pines on July 4 and the Pines Party in late July.
  • Book direct. Locèlle introduces you to the owners so you can book with them without platform fees.

Best time to visit

Memorial Day to Labor Day is the season, when ferries run often and the harbor bars and restaurants are open. July and August are the busiest months, with the Invasion of the Pines on July 4 and the Pines Party in late July. June and September are quieter, with warm days and easier bookings. Outside the summer, ferry schedules are reduced and many businesses close.

Getting there

Fire Island Pines and Cherry Grove are reached by passenger ferry from Sayville on Long Island, a short crossing of the Great South Bay. From Manhattan, take the Long Island Rail Road to Sayville and a short taxi or shuttle to the ferry terminal, or drive and park at the terminal. Cars are not allowed in the Pines, so plan to arrive with what you can carry or pull in a wagon.

Things to do nearby

  • The Pines harbor: Low Tea at the Blue Whale, High Tea at the Pavilion and dinner overlooking the boats.
  • The ocean beach: a wide Atlantic beach a short walk down the boardwalks.
  • Cherry Grove: about a mile west along the sand, with bayside bars, drag shows and its community theater.
  • The Sunken Forest: a boardwalk trail through a centuries-old maritime holly forest at Sailors Haven, in Fire Island National Seashore.
  • Fire Island Lighthouse: at the western end of the island, with views along the coast.

Free booking guide

Stop paying the booking-fee tax

Our free guide shows you how to book design-led homes like these directly with the owner, and keep the 15 to 20 percent that platforms add to every night.

Good to know

Frequently asked questions

How do I get to Fire Island Pines?

Take the ferry from Sayville on Long Island. From Manhattan, the Long Island Rail Road runs to Sayville, and a short taxi or shuttle connects the station to the ferry.

Can I bring a car to Fire Island Pines?

No. The Pines is car-free. You park on Long Island and walk the boardwalks once you arrive.

When is Fire Island busiest?

July and August, especially around July 4 and the Pines Party in late July. June and September are quieter.

Do you charge booking fees?

No. Locèlle connects you directly with the owner, so you book with them without added platform fees.

Keep exploring

More places to stay

From the Journal

Guides and stories

Just added

New to Locèlle

Every home books directly with its host. No platform fees.

Find your next unique stay

Browse every design-forward home on Locèlle and book direct with the owner. No middleman.

Explore all homes