Sleep in a Church, a Schoolhouse, or a Treehouse: Halloween-Ready Stays for Design Lovers

Most "spooky season" travel content is about corn mazes and haunted hayrides. This isn't that. These are three real, design-forward properties with the kind of architectural backstory that makes an October weekend feel like it belongs in a different century — a former church, a converted one-room schoolhouse, and a treehouse hidden among the ferns. No gimmicks, no jump scares. Just atmosphere that's earned.

A Converted Church in the Catskills

Phillipsport Church House — Wurtsboro, NY Once a place of worship, now a peaceful getaway with soaring ceilings and the kind of quiet that only a former sanctuary can hold. Sleeps up to 6 across 5 bedrooms — big enough for a group Halloween weekend without anyone sharing a room. Read the full story behind the restoration in Phillipsport Church House: A Unique Converted Church Rental in the Catskills.

A One-Room Schoolhouse in the Finger Lakes Region

Wheatland Schoolhouse No. 7 Retreat — Churchville, NY A historic schoolhouse restored down to the bones by its owners, Nicholas & James. There's something fitting about spending a fall weekend in a building that's been holding stories for over a century. Sleeps 4. Full history in Wheatland Schoolhouse: A Historic Converted Rental in Churchville, NY.

A Treehouse Hidden in the Ferns

Muddy Brook Treehouse — Phoenicia, NY For a quieter kind of eerie — the fog rolling through the Catskills, a brook running below, and a treehouse you can't fully see until you're standing under it. Sleeps 4. Meet the owners behind it in Muddy Brook Treehouse: A Design-Forward Catskills Rental.

Why October Is the Right Month for These Three

Each of these homes has a story that a summer trip doesn't do justice to. October's shorter days, cooler nights, and the first bit of fog rolling through the mountains give all three properties their full effect — the kind of atmosphere you can't manufacture with string lights and a fog machine.

If you're building a longer Catskills weekend around one of these stays, pair it with our guide to things to do in the Catskills or browse the best design-led cabins in the Catskills for a second night somewhere different.

Book Direct, No Fees

All three homes are available to book directly with the owner — browse unique stays in the Catskills or see the full collection of listings on Locèlle.

‍