Sleep in a Church, a Schoolhouse, or a Treehouse: Halloween-Ready Stays for Design Lovers

Most "spooky season" travel content is about corn mazes and haunted hayrides. This isn't that. These are three real, design-forward properties with the kind of architectural backstory that makes an October weekend feel like it belongs in a different century — a former church, a converted one-room schoolhouse, and a treehouse hidden among the ferns. No gimmicks, no jump scares. Just atmosphere that's earned.

A Converted Church in the Catskills

Phillipsport Church House — Wurtsboro, NY Once a place of worship, now a peaceful getaway with soaring ceilings and the kind of quiet that only a former sanctuary can hold. Sleeps up to 6 across 5 bedrooms — big enough for a group Halloween weekend without anyone sharing a room. Read the full story behind the restoration in Phillipsport Church House: A Unique Converted Church Rental in the Catskills.

A One-Room Schoolhouse in the Finger Lakes Region

Wheatland Schoolhouse No. 7 Retreat — Churchville, NY A historic schoolhouse restored down to the bones by its owners, Nicholas & James. There's something fitting about spending a fall weekend in a building that's been holding stories for over a century. Sleeps 4. Full history in Wheatland Schoolhouse: A Historic Converted Rental in Churchville, NY.

A Treehouse Hidden in the Ferns

Muddy Brook Treehouse — Phoenicia, NY For a quieter kind of eerie — the fog rolling through the Catskills, a brook running below, and a treehouse you can't fully see until you're standing under it. Sleeps 4. Meet the owners behind it in Muddy Brook Treehouse: A Design-Forward Catskills Rental.

Why October Is the Right Month for These Three

Each of these homes has a story that a summer trip doesn't do justice to. October's shorter days, cooler nights, and the first bit of fog rolling through the mountains give all three properties their full effect — the kind of atmosphere you can't manufacture with string lights and a fog machine.

If you're building a longer Catskills weekend around one of these stays, pair it with our guide to things to do in the Catskills or browse the best design-led cabins in the Catskills for a second night somewhere different.

Book Direct, No Fees

All three homes are available to book directly with the owner — browse unique stays in the Catskills or see the full collection of listings on Locèlle.

‍

Justin Henry
About the editor

Justin Henry is the founder and editor of Locèlle, telling the stories of design-led homes and the people who build them.

Read the letter from the founders

Own a home with a story of its own? Submit your home to Locèlle

Get the Drops
Be first to new stays
Owners share new homes with us before they're listed anywhere else. Get them first in a weekly email, and book direct with the owner.
We just sent you a 6-digit code. Check your inbox and paste it below.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Articles for you
Cozy bedroom with neutral tones, textured bedding, a plant on a side table, and framed wall art.

New homes, before they're public

One email a week with new design-led stays, owner stories and off-market finds. Free, and easy to unsubscribe.

Get early access
Cozy bedroom with neutral tones, textured bedding, a plant on a side table, and framed wall art.

New homes, before they're public

One email a week with new design-led stays, owner stories and off-market finds. Free, and easy to unsubscribe.

Get early access
featured listings

Stay somewhere with a story

Every home books directly with its host. No platform fees.

The journal

Insights, collaborations, and stories worth exploring